A Lahore citizen, Ashba Kamran, has written to the Punjab Governor questioning the legality of appointing a serving federal minister and a CM adviser to Aitchison College’s Board of Governors.
LAHORE: Serious questions have been raised over recent appointments to the Board of Governors of Aitchison College, one of Pakistan’s most prestigious schools.
In a strongly worded letter dated November 20, 2026, Lahore resident Ashba Kamran wrote to the Governor of Punjab, the Board’s president. She called the appointments “a serious failure of institutional governance” by both the federal and Punjab governments.
A federal minister on a provincial board?
The letter questions the inclusion of Ali Pervaiz Malik, whom it describes as a serving federal minister. Kamran says Aitchison College is governed under a Punjab provincial law. She asks what legal justification allows a federal minister to sit on its governing body, and under which provision of the Punjab Educational Institutions (Reconstitution) Act, 2021, he was appointed.
Adviser in a minister’s seat
The letter also challenges the inclusion of Ali Mustafa Dar, Adviser to the Chief Minister. Kamran argues that Section 4(1)(a) of the 2021 Act gives ex-officio membership only to the minister in charge of the relevant department. She says the Act makes no mention of an adviser.
Who really made the appointments?
Kamran also asks whether the Governor used his own statutory authority under Section 4 of the Act, or simply accepted political nominations from the Punjab government. She further asks whether the Chief Minister’s oath under Article 130 of the Constitution has been honored, or whether political influence has overridden institutional independence.
“Political office is not an educational qualification,” the letter states.
7-day deadline
Kamran has demanded a formal, point-by-point response within 7 working days, along with the appointment notifications and their legal justification. She warns that silence will only deepen public concerns about transparency and political interference at the college.
Ashba Kamran’s letter:

No response from the Governor’s House or the Punjab government had been reported at the time of publication.

