Why was the price of the shopping bag charged? After Khaadi, renowned brand NDURE also fined.
Judge Nasrullah Khan Gandapur of the Peshawar Consumer Court has imposed a total fine of Rs 40,020 on the renowned footwear brand NDURE (Ndure) for charging extra money for a shopping bag. In its decision,
the court ordered the brand to return Rs 20 charged for the shopping bag to the complainant consumer Sarah Sial, pay her Rs 20,000 in damages, and deposit a further Rs 20,000 in the national treasury.
An important aspect of this case is also swift justice, as the woman had filed the complaint on October 23 and just three weeks later, on November 14, the written decision of the court was also issued.
According to the details of the incident, the complainant woman had bought shoes worth Rs 4,999 from an NDURE outlet on October 11, 2026, however the company charged her an extra Rs 20 for a shopping bag on which the brand’s name was also printed. After hearing,
the court in its written decision held that the company used the consumer as a marketing agent to advertise its brand and also charged for the bag given for this purpose, which is an unfair trade practice and a clear violation of consumer rights.
The decision further stated that the consumer had come to the shop to buy shoes and the branded shopping bag was not an essential part of the purchased products, therefore charging a separate price for it is not correct.
In this decision, the court also referred to the decision given in September against the renowned brand Khaadi on a complaint of the same nature, in which Khaadi was fined Rs 50,030.

